Love Across Traditions

Key Reading Paths

1. Symposium: praise of love

   Begin with one speech, then compare the arguments of the later speakers.

2. Augustine: friendship and loss

   Ask how the experience of grief changes the narrator’s account of attachment.

3. Bhagavad Gita: devotion

   Compare devotion with the disciplines and qualities it requires.

Questions for comparison

The word “love” can name desire, friendship, devotion, or care, but these forms do not ask the same things of a person. Let the comparison reveal differences in what love seeks and how it judges its own demands.

• What does love want? Compare a speech in the Symposium with Augustine’s account of friendship and the Gita’s account of devotion. Is love directed toward a particular person, an enduring good, or a transformed way of living?
• Does love seek possession or another’s freedom? Find a moment where attachment makes a claim on another being. What in the text helps distinguish care from the wish to secure something for oneself?
• Can loss change the meaning of attachment? In Augustine, separate the remembered bond from the later interpretation of it. Does grief disclose the value of love, its dangers, or both?
• What must a loving person become? Read the qualities associated with devotion in the Gita beside the Symposium’s accounts of desire and education. Is love an emotion to undergo, a practice to cultivate, or a force that changes one’s aims?
• How does a voice persuade us to call something love? Attend to the difference between praise, confession, and instruction. What might another speaker say about the attachment being described?

Teaching with these readings

Begin by withholding a single definition. Ask students to collect the actions and expectations associated with love in one passage. Compare these with a second passage before deciding which experiences belong under the same term.

Follow a demand love makes. Choose a claim about what one person or devotee should give, endure, or relinquish. Students investigate the grounds of that claim and ask what would make it excessive or justifiable within the text’s own framework.

Bring a literary relationship into the inquiry. Read an encounter in a novel or epic alongside the philosophical or religious account. Ask what the concept clarifies and what the particular person’s response makes harder to explain.

Revise through the other voice. Students argue for a difference between two forms of attachment, then consider the perspective of someone affected by one of them. The final response should distinguish the text’s account from the student’s judgment and show where the comparison has changed their initial definition.

Continue exploring